Choosing & running content management systemsIndependent, vendor-neutral guides
CCMS CompassCMS Guide

Choosing a CMS

Migrating From One CMS to Another Without Disaster

7 min read · Updated 2026-07-10

Sometimes you outgrow a CMS, or inherit one that no longer fits, and migration becomes necessary. It's one of the riskier things you can do to a website: done carelessly, you can lose content, break links, tank your search rankings, and create weeks of chaos. Done carefully, it's a manageable project that sets the site up for years. The difference is planning. The redirect and indexing steps are covered in detail by the Google site-move documentation.

Why migrations go wrong

Most migration disasters come from underestimating the work and rushing. Content gets lost or mangled in the move, URLs change and break every existing link and search ranking, functionality that worked before doesn't afterward, and there's no way back when something fails. Nearly all of this is preventable with planning, testing, and a few key precautions, but skipped preparation is how sites get wrecked. A migration plan is stronger when owners act before problems become urgent; a related workplace perspective is available in this reference.

The danger in a migration isn't the new platform. It's the rushing, the untested move, and the forgotten redirects.

Migrating safely

Redirects protect your traffic

The single most commonly forgotten step, and the most damaging, is redirects. When URLs change, every old link, bookmark, and search result points to a dead page unless you redirect it to the new location. Skipping this can erase search rankings built over years overnight. Mapping old URLs to new ones and setting up proper redirects is tedious but essential; it's what preserves the traffic and authority the old site earned.

Never skip the redirects: map every old URL to its new home and set up redirects before launch. It's the step that protects the search rankings and links your site spent years building.